Total Pageviews

Showing posts with label Hot Wheels. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hot Wheels. Show all posts

Sunday, July 21, 2024

Who makes the best of the Mercedes 560 SEC / 500 SEC - the coolest, most bad-ass car of the late 1980s - the “I’m a Miami drug kingpin, this is my car - don’t mess with me!!!”?

For 35 years I've thought the Mercedes Benz 560 SEC, especially in modified AMG form, was one of the coolest, most-intimidating looking cars on the road.  The SEC was already the best looking, most expensive, most powerful coupe on the road in the late 1980s (with only the exotic Aston Vantage having any ability to challenge it).  And the AMG version of the SEC doubled the SEC’s already crazy price, adding power, presence and speed in equal measure.  The resulting car made even a Lamborghini Countach look like a bratty pouser, with more presence than almost anything else on the road!


And the Matchbox model (technically of the rest-of-the-world 500 SEC) did a great job of capturing that essence - a big meaty bruiser of a luxury coupe - making it one of my favorite castings of the post-lesney era - and a frequent subject of this blog.  I've got it in many colors - though there still remain a number of variations that I DON'T have it in.  

But recently, Hot Wheels introduced its own basic series casting of the same car - and it’s a phenomenal casting - easily my favorite Hot Wheels basic casting of the last few years.  I've found it in black, red, and grey/silver.  As cool as the vintage Matchbox is, this new Hot Wheels casting had something about it that was different than the Matchbox - with more sculpted rear wheel arches - slightly more streamlined and proportional bodywork, with the gotta-play-with-it essence that makes for a great diecast model.  I couldn’t help feeling like this HAD to result in a throw down comparison test.  

But THEN….  …I found a vintage Road Champs model of the 500SEC, in a rich shade of dark blue, with opening doors and a metal base!  A great car and a great find… ...and as long as I was including THAT one, I felt I had to also include Yatming's version of the 500SEC, particularly since it was one of Yatming’s stronger models, again with opening doors and metal base.  I have 2 of that casting in identical silver paint.  

All of which sets up for a compelling comparison test!

While all 4 castings are undeniably cool on their own, all great models, all faithfully replicating the coolness of the authentic SEC, all with certain advantages…. …still not all of the 4 castings compete at the same level.  In any competition there are winners and non-winners, and that is certainly the case here.

As much as I root for the underdog, and like the early high-quality Yatming castings, the Yatming is unquestionably the laggard of the group - it makes for an easy-to-determine 4th place finish.   It’s still a great casting, with a real metal base, a separate insert for the front grill/bumper/headlights (though that insert looks a little cheaply/plasticky), good detail, a soft suspension, opening doors, cream-colored interior, etc., etc., etc.  On its own, it’s great, but in comparison to the others, it just doesn’t look as tough as the others.  The Matchbox and Hot Wheels are models of the AMG modified SEC, whereas the Yatming and the Road Champs are models of the normal (still very nice!) Mercedes, and the difference is evident.  It just looks less muscular than the Matchbox and Hot Wheels…. …and it relegates the Yatming to a (strong) last place.

The next casting that gets eliminated is the Road Champs, really for the same reason as the Yatming.  It’s essentially a nicer version of the Yatming, a better model of the normal SEC rather than the ultra-tough AMG monster SEC.  …But the regular SEC still oozed class, more class than anything on the road aside from a Bentley Turbo R, and here the Road Champs finds its niche.  It beats the nice Yatming in almost every category (save for perhaps the silkiness of its suspension).  It’s bigger, meatier, with richer classy dark blue paint, a more substantial baseplate, a metal insert for the front clip that drips with detail (down to the headlight windshield wipers!), a cast-in-metal 3-pointed star on the hood, a glass sunroof, etc. etc. etc.  This is a Great model!  …but just not as great as the next 2 models.  I love it - but not enough to move it beyond 3rd place. 


If the voting was hard earlier, it gets even harder at this point…. Both the original Matchbox and the new Hot Wheels are REALLY nice competitors.  The Matchbox has a silky soft suspension, a heavy feel, great metal detail, and opening doors.  But it has its own downfalls - chief of which is that it looks a little fat and tall, especially when viewed against the more accurately proportionately modeled Hot Wheels.  Plus, the Hot Wheels colors are just on fire.  In addition, the detail on the Hot Wheels is over the top, with a vented-open sunroof (a first-ever in a diecast car?), speaker cutouts on the interior rear shelf, the best dual-exhaust of the bunch, modern-era paint detail for the front and especially rear lights, etc.

And so the new Hot Wheels casting wins - even without opening doors - and against one of my all-time favorite Matchbox cars, and against amazing contenders from Yatming and Road Champs.  That being said, (and I know I say this all the time!), all 4 models are phenemonal castings, there’s not a true loser in the bunch.  All 4 competitors are truly worthy adversaries!  

I’ve got to SAY, what a TOY!










Saturday, March 30, 2024

Which is the best of the recent hyper-premium (RLC and above) Porsche 911s from Hot Wheels and Matchbox?

Recently, several hyper-premium (RLC-quality) Porsche 911s have been released, including:

1. an ultra-expensive Hot Wheels "Mattel Creations" Daniel Arsham Porsche 930 (late '70's 911 Turbo) in white, 
2. a Hot Wheels "RLC Exclusive" Porsche 964 911 "Magnus Walker" "Urban Outlaw" in mint green, 
3. a "Matchbox Collectors" 1980 Porsche 911 Turbo in a pepto-bismal pink.  

All of these cars originally retailed on the Hot Wheels/Matchbox Collectors website for $30+ (including shipping) (the Arsham Porsche was twice that amount), and all sold out immediately.  I bought them on Ebay after the fact, and had to pay roughly $40 each for the 2 less expensive ones, and $130 for the Arsham Creations one.  

Just a few years ago I couldn't imagine ever paying more than $10 for a single car.  And now, I'm writing a blog entry about 3 cars - 2 of which were $40 and 1 of which was $130?!?  Seriously?!?  

So given the relatively insane price points of all of these cars, you'd be forgiven for wondering whether ANY of them are worth the price, and, if you were just going to splurge for 1 of them, which one was the nicest...  

So let me cut to the chase.  They are ALL extremely nice.  All of the paint jobs are spectacular.  All are wonderful models. If you can afford (stomach?) the price points to buy them all, then buy them all.  Period.  
But there are a lot more questions that you may have, such as:

1.  Are they actually worth $40 to $130 each?  

Well, that completely depends on your own financial circumstances and views on toy car value.  But I can at least assure you that they are "nice" models.  

2.  But more importantly - which is nicer?  How do they stack up?  If you were to only buy 1 of them, which should you buy?  

For this question, I have an easy answer for you.  Third place is clearly the pink Matchbox.  Its a nice model, but it just can't compete with the 2 Hot Wheels cars.  So if you don't want to buy them all - then cut out the Matchbox first.  

The race between first and second place is much closer, and so close that it may come down to personal preference, but for me, the ultra-expensive white Arsham studio car wins out over the green 964.  If you only buy 1 car, buy the white 930.  On the other hand, if value for the money is considered, then the green 964 easily wins - since it is just 1/3 the price point of the white 930 - but almost its equal.  

There you have it - that's my judgment!  

Now read on - for a more detailed description of each of the cars!

Pink Matchbox:  This is a very nice car.  In fact, if you view it on its own, you'll really like it, with a nice casting body, amazing paint, and great wheels.  Viewed on its own, the "gotta-have-it" factor definitely kicks in.

The paint detail is amazing - the rear lights detail is the best of the 3.  The deep-dish FUCHS wheels are period correct - even if I'm not crazy about the superman blue color of them.  The opening doors is a nice touch.  Finally - the thickness of the whaletail rear-spoiler feels just perfect - I didn't realize that other whale tail spoilers were way too thick and clunky until I looked at this Matchbox one in detail..

There ARE a few negatives...:  Most importantly - I think the casting is a reused casting from the earlier "moving parts" series.  While the moving parts 911 turbo was a nice casting, this materially more expensive version of the same casting doesn't give you much more to justify the higher price tag.  Are you really willing to shell out $40 to get what is basically a color variation (albeit - a very nice color variation) of a casting that you probably already have?!?  

Plus, the base is PLASTIC, which feels pretty cheapy at this price level.  The color choice for the black interior is unfortunate - the 2 Hot Wheels interiors are lighter with tons of painted-in detail, making the Matchbox's straight black somber interior seem cheap in comparison.  And finally, while the overall paint quality is great and the color scheme works, I just can't quite decide how I feel about a pepto-bismal-pink 911...!  

Again, while the prior paragraphs may make me sound as though I'm not a fan of this model, it's not true.  It is a VERY nice model.  But its not perfect - and its just not quite in the same league as the even NICER Hot Wheels models.  That all makes it an easy 3rd place finish.  

That leaves us with the 2 Hot Wheels premium models - a 964 against a 930, and this time the race is CLOSE.  Both models are absolute exquisite, almost jewel-like in their detail.  

The green 964 initially catches your eye more than the white 930 - mostly because of the mirror-like reflective quality to the paint.  But actually the paint is SO reflective that it is a little unrealistic, such that AFTER that first initial impression, I began to be less high about the paint.  

The opening trunk is a nice touch , with a highly detailed engine bay.  I love the custom after-market gold wheels (though I've read other internet commentary that didn't like the wheels).  The interior is beige, but with an absolutely beautiful tartan insert on the seats that just takes it over-the-top.  With its metal base, the model has a nice heft that the plastic base Matchbox can't touch.  Overall, this is an amazing model - well worth even the $30-40 entry purchase price - and it's hard to imagine that anything could beat it. 

But then you look at the white Arsham studio 930...   ...and...  ...you just can't take your eyes off of it!  The white paint is...  ...amazing...?  ...flawless...?  ...perfect in execution and choice of color...?  How much more complementary can I get about it?

Simply put - I love the color.  In addition, the paint detail is equally great/perfect.  

The wheels are beyond perfect (aside from the tires oddly saying "Arsham Studio" on them when they should say "Pirelli" or "Goodyear").  I absolutely love the choice of wheels/design of the wheels.  

The interior is off white - with beautiful contrasting seating surface trim.  I couldn't imagine having a nicer interior - that is until I compare it to the 964's interior - with its amazing tartan inserts (c'mon Hot Wheels - why couldn't you have given us those Tartan inserts on this car?!?).    

So, in sum, the Arsham 911 wins, eclipsing even the amazing 964 (albeit for a LOT more money).  

Again - all 3 cars are great pieces.  If you have the funds, buy all of them.  If you can only buy 1, splurge for the Arsham 930.  If you can't afford the Arsham, then buy the 964.  You can't go wrong with any of them!

Saturday, February 12, 2022

Thoughts and advice from 25 years of re-spraying diecast cars (along with a few pictures of some recent projects!)

Although I'm far from an expert on re-painting Matchbox and Hot Wheels cars, I've been doing it on an amateur basis for going on 25 years now, so I thought I'd share some of my advice about how to do it well, along with some photos of some recently sprayed cars.

The format of this blog-post will be some very basic advice (for someone who's never done this at all), followed by my more in-depth top 15 advice list.  

Basic Steps (that many readers will already know):

1.  Disassembly is a must:  Why?  Because even the steadiest hand and the finest brush won't allow you to brush paint right up to the windows, without getting it ON the windows.  You HAVE to take the windows out.  Plus, without taking the windows out, the inside metal of the car won't be painted, and will still be visible in the old color.  

We've all seen the gross flea market cars where some kid has attempted to change the color of the car, using some poster/tempura paint, with paint all over the windows, or WITHOUT paint in the new color going all the way up to the window.  So bite the bullet and realize that although disassembly is a pain, it makes everything MUCH easier...  

2.  How do you disassemble a car?  Easy (in concept), just drill out the rivets.  Most cars have 2 rivets on the bottom, one at the front and one at the back (though older Lesney cars sometimes have 2 rivets at the back, for a total of 3 (not including a potential rivet to hold the window glass in place)). 

Get a good and sharp set of drill bits, and start with the tiniest drill bit (this one will take the longest since you are getting the hole started) in the middle of the rivet, and go about 1/8th-1/16th of an inch deep.  Once the first pilot hole is done, just start moving up the drill bit sizes.  Most times you'll only need about 5-10 seconds of drilling as you move to a larger size - since the drill will immediately catch/bite using the original hole and expand the hold to the new size.  Do all 2-3 rivets for the car (or cars if you are doing multiple cars at the same time) before switching to the next largest drill bit.  Eventually you'll almost completely (90%?) drill out the rivet and suddenly the remains of the rivet will break, and the car will suddenly pop apart.  Once you have 1 rivet popped, you can start pulling apart the baseplate from the top of the car, and the other rivet(s) will quickly pop as well.  

Most cars have 4 main pieces - the diecast body (top), the baseplate (metal on old cars, plastic on new cars), an interior, and the plastic glass, plus the 2 axles with wheels.  Older cars may have more than 4 pieces (opening doors are individual pieces, sometimes there are multiple body pieces, or separate grills, etc.).  It'll all be pretty obvious once you get the car apart.  

On older cars (which are my favorites - and so also my favorites to respray) the glass is often held in place with another rivet on the underside of the roof.  For the glass rivet, I actually use a really large (wide) drill bit, since if I start with a tiny drill and try to make a pilot hole I'll actually drill right through the roof.  Instead I just try to remove enough of the expanded part of the rivot to allow the glass to pull away from the roof.  

3.  Paint ONLY using spray paint:  Again - this is a fairly hard and fast rule.  Don't try to brush paint a car - since you'll have lots of brush marks at the end, and the paint won't be smooth.  Spray painting is THE way to go to get a nice, smooth, professional looking finish (more on this later).  I've brush painted trim (headlights, taillights, sometimes grills, etc.) with moderate success.  But I've had very little success brush paining body panels (like doing a 2 tone paint job) since again the paint often dries with visible rough paint marks, and my hand is just not steady enough to make clean and straight lines with a brush.

The one exception to the brush painting advice is interior plastic...  In real life I really like brown leather car interiors, and so I often brush paint interiors in a tan or chestnut shade.   For some reason the plastic doesn't show up brush strokes.  Paint the interior a normal color (sometimes the casting will have a green or purple or sparkly interior which is entirely unrealistic and which NEEDS to be changed), and change black interiors (black absorbs light and hides detail) to a color that can actually be seen!

Top 15 advice list:

15.  Don't even start this project if you are not detail oriented/a perfectionist!  It's finicky, intricate, detail oriented stuff that you are doing.  If you aren't detail oriented, or don't really care about it, then it's just not worth doing.  Save yourself the time now!  But on the other hand if you are detail oriented and you love your diecast cars, then re-spraying them into a new car is a very do-able and satisfying project!

14.  The final project will be cool - but it's debatable HOW much you'll like it and if you will think that the time and expense were justified in the end.  If there is a color variation that already exists in the same color that you want to paint it in, then just go on EBay and buy that color variation.  It'll be much easier and cheaper (and more valuable)!  

13.  The final product will be valueless:   In general, code 3 (customized) cars are not worth anything besides their curiosity value.  So DON'T paint a high value nice condition car (it's a bad investment - plus it'll piss off other collectors who will think you ruined it!).  YOU are probably the only person who will truly appreciate the end-product!

12.  Be realistic about the time required:  Painting cars always takes longer (a LOT longer) than I expect.  This is not a one hour project!  

11.  (Related to #12 above)  Do more than one car at a time:  Doing multiple cars allows you to pick up some volume efficiencies from doing each of the various steps.  But don't do TOO many cars - or else you'll get overwhelmed, you'll get tired and start to rush, or it'll get too hard to remember which parts go with which car.  In my opinion about 4-5 cars is the optimal number to do at any one time.  

10.  (Related to #12 above...)  Patience is key.  Don't rush, take your time.  It's ok to redo a step.  

9.  Choose your projects carefully:  Only do cars/castings that you really like.  If you don't like the casting design BEFORE you paint it, you won't like it that much more AFTER you paint it.  And if you don't like it, you won't be inspired to really put the time and energy and patience into making the final project look terrific.

Also consider the condition of the cars that you are doing.  While scratched window glass can be mostly repaired (dip the glass into a container of MopandGlo and let it dry - the MopandGlo will fill in the scratches amazingly), I've never figured out how to repair/unbend axles (though there are plenty of guys out there who CAN do this), and I've never figured out a good way to repaint wheels without having the new paint look all blobby.  So either be OK with the faded wheel paint, or replace them with new wheels from other donor cars (easier said than done - since the wheels and axles need to be the same size and width or they won't work!).  

In summary - do cars that are in poor enough condition that you don't feel bad about ruining their originality, but in good enough condition that the unrestored parts of them won't detract from the new paint

8.  Spray painting cars is both incredibly easy... ...but can also be surprisingly tough.  Do smooth passes, a few inches away from the car.  I put the car on a painting block that I made on 8 inch lengths of 2 inch wide pine boards, sitting on nails pounded into the board (to keep the bottom lip of the body from touching the block), which allows me to turn the block for different passes from different angles.  Do the passes slow enough that you get good paint coverage, but not so slow that the paint collects on it and starts to drip/run.  You DON'T want thick paint - it'll dry funny - and it obscures all the great Lesney detail that made you like the car in the first place!  If you get the paint on too thick, just wipe it off with paint thinner (a NECESSARY item to have for this project) and respray it.  Allow the paint to slightly dry (10-20 minutes) between coats.  Allow the paint to dry much more (several hours) before handling the casting AT ALL , or before turning the casting upside down to do the inside and bottom (as well as getting a different angle on the outside of the casting).  In the unlikely scenario that the paint is NOT covering and you keep on adding more coats and it continues to not cover - it's probably too wet and is running.  Let it dry (or if already too drippy - wipe it off and start over).  

7.  Choose your paint carefully.  Get several different colors and types of paints.  Some paints work great - others don't - even if they are from the same brand/type of paints.  

Choose your colors carefully as well.  Some colors look great - others just don't.  About 10-20% of the time I'll spray a car and then think that I just don't like the way the color looks - it's too dark, or too muted, or too crazy and unrealistic, or just wrong somehow, and I'll wipe it off and redo it in a different color.  

I've had REALLY good luck with metallic colors - bronzes, coppers, silvers, etc.  You'll see several of these colors in the photos of the recently done cars.  In fact, that bronze color on the Lesney Mercury sedan and Scania tractor is my FAVORITE paint color ever - I've probably done 10+ cars in that paint color (and it's a big standard sized Rustoleum spray paint can available for $5 from any WalMart/Home Depot).  When I first started spraying cars I used the little 4 inch Testor cans available from hobby Shops - but I'm not convinced that those Testor cans are any better than standard (and much cheaper on a per ounce basis) Rustoleum cans (though the Testor cans DO come in a wider variety of colors!).  

When choosing a color - think about how realistic it will be.  Most real cars are painted white, black, silver or red.  Unfortunately, I haven't had great luck with the particular white or red shades that I've tried so far.  And I don't like black since it hides rather than shows detail.  Painting a luxury car a wild shade of purple or lime green is going to look a bit odd, though those can be great colors for muscle cars.   

6.   You don't need to strip all the paint from the old casting, but consider sanding it a bit to hide any existing paint chips:  Using paint stripper is messy, gross, environmentally unfriendly and it adds a lot of time to the process.  Most spray paints will provide excellent color coverage, and you won't see the old paint once the new paint is on.  However, if the old paint was significantly chipped, you MAY see the outline of the chips clearly visible in the new paint.  Therefore while I've stopped stripping the castings, I DO use a Dremel tool with a wire brush wheel attached to quickly sand/smooth the old paint and smooth down any chips. I don't worry about getting every speck of the old paint off unless it is really thick and blobby, or if it is so thick that it hides important metal detail in the casting.

5.  Have fun and consider additional customizations while you've got the car apart.  There are lots of customizations that are possible to do to a car besides just painting it.  The Mercury sedan in the foreground of the right-hand photo only came in a police/fire car, with an emergency police/fire light (in various shapes) on the roof.  So before I painted this car, I first ground down the lip surrounding the light (with a dremel tool), then I filled in the light hole with metal solder.  While the final result isn't perfect (you can see that the roof isn't perfectly smooth), I'm still pretty happy with it, and I now have a normal (non-Police/Fire) sedan that was never actually made by Lesney!  

Other customizations that I've done include:  1.  Cutting the roof off and making a convertible (cutting the roof off is easy with a Dremel cutting blade, but reforming the back deck into the shape of a convertible top can be pretty difficult), 2.  doing base plate swaps with other versions of the same casting, 3.  changing wheels, 4.  eliminating or adding huge off-road wheels (be warned that this can be pretty hard, etc.  

4.  Be VERY careful of fingerprints:  Avoid any serious handling of the car until the paint has had a chance to harden (overnight is best).   If not, when you pressing the hood/trunk/roof of the car to re-mate it to the baseplate - you'll transfer your fingerprints into the paint.  Seriously.  Learn from my mistakes - I've done this mistake WAY too many times!  

3.  The paint on repainted castings is VERY fragile:  For some reasons, it chips really easily.  I estimate that a repainted car will chip about 10 times easier than original paint.  I've chipped repainted cars just placing them back into cases!  I don't know why this is - I've tried adding primer and clear coat and they don't seem to make much of a difference (but feel free to experiment yourself!)

2.  Skip the primer and clear coat: Although you'd think that primer and clear coat would provide more protection and more durability, I'm frankly not convinced.  They add additional painting time (and more importantly - drying time).  Primer adds the possibility of being sprayed on too thickly and obscuring detail.  And clear coat can change the color of a lighter paint shade.  At this point, I just don't feel that their benefits offset their disadvantages - but I'll keep on experimenting and maybe I'll change my mind again!

1.  Use superglue to put the whole thing back together:  Serious restorers tap new screws and screw the body back together.  But I've never figured out how to do this - and frankly - superglue is a lot easier! 

Finally, enjoy your new and unique look!

Wednesday, February 10, 2021

944 Turbos... The new Hot Wheels casting of one of my favorite cars is awesome. ...But can it compete with the Original Matchbox version???

I've always wanted a 944 Turbo.  It was the hot car when I was in high school - cheaper but faster than a 911 Carrera, and with classic late '80s looks.  So when Hot Wheels released a retro 944 turbo this year - in both red and gold - and maybe more colors to come - I went crazy over it.  The shape is just right, the wheels are cool, etc.  


But the Matchbox version from the Matchbox Toys International era is the OG, and one of my favorite castings from that time.  So is the new How Wheels version it's equal?






























Simply put, no.  It's no comparison at all.  Pulling out the Matchbox version - in red, green and amazing yellow - let alone the premium red version - instantly shows that the Matchbox is way better.  The 2 castings are almost identical in size - and both are nicely detailed - but the all-metal construction of the Matchbox gives it much more of a quality heft, the Matchbox has opening doors, and the soft suspension of the Matchbox (vs. the rock-hard ride of the new Hot Wheels) all conspire to eliminate any hope of a close competition.  


It doesn't make me love the Hot Wheels any less.  It's a great model.  And I'm thrilled with Hot Wheels for bringing out these retro cars.  I just love the Matchbox castings more!  


Tuesday, October 8, 2019

New vs. Old Comparison Test - Lifted Off-Road Jeep Grand Wagoneers.... Vintage Majorette vs. New "Premium" Hot Wheels!

Well readers...   ...its been a while!  Over a year, in fact, since my last post. 

However a recent crop of premium models from Hot Wheels and Matchbox have inspired me to blog again.  Today's post is motivated by the recently introduced premium Hot Wheels series called "Desert Rally", a 5-car line that includes a beautiful 1988 Jeep Grand Wagoneer, all jacked-up with huge off-road wheels.  Being as its part of the premium line, the entire casting is metal, giving it a nice weighty feel, and the paint and trim work is excellent.  So excellent in fact, that I started wondering how it would compare with one of my favorite models from my childhood - the Majorette Jeep Cherokee Chief, itself all jacked-up with huge off-road tires. 

While the vintage Majorette model is a 2 door late '70's Jeep and the Hot Wheels is a 4 door Grand Wagoneer from 1988, in fact the 10-year apart vehicles were based on the same platform - just slightly (ever so slightly!) - updated to try to keep the Grand Wagoneer relevant in the late '80s. 

Which means that its time for a "Matchbox Frenzy" comparison test... Who modeled it better - Majorette or Hot Wheels - and can a premium model from 2019 upstage a stalwart mainstay of the 1980's Majorette line?

But to be candid, as soon as I dug out the vintage Majorette casting, I knew that it was going to be the winner of the comparison test.  The Hot Wheels may be newer, and glitzier, with fresh paint, but the Majorette just has more heft and presence.  Although the Hot Wheels casting is nicely sized, the Majorette is still larger than the Hot Wheels, and feels more authentic in its square-jaw'd ruggedness.  Nowhere is the size difference more visible than from above - looking down at the roofs of both vehicles - with the Majorette's roof clearly dwarfing the narrow white roof of the Hot Wheels. 

As a kid who grew up in the era when these Jeep wagons were one of the few options for a luxury family SUV, I liked the looks of the Grand Wagoneer's grill, and remember it better than the earlier Cherokee grill.  The Hot Wheels grill is modeled well in all metal, with nice detail - including a winch.  But modeled in 1/64 scale, the Cherokee grill on the Majorette comes across simpler and more authentic than that of the Hot Wheels - which (only in comparison) seems too polished up - and just maybe slightly gaudy. 

The wheels of the Hot Wheels model are nicer than the standard big wheels of the Majorette.  Plus the tires are rubber rather than plastic.  Advantage Hot Wheels. 

Paint-wise - the Hot Wheels paint is terrific - a beautiful teal color - with lots and lots and LOTS of detail.  In comparison - the Majorette's paint is a horribly out of date shade of light orange...  But then again, the faded and chipped paint feels more authentic for an off-road truck.  Advantage?  Tie!

But this isn't going to be a comparison test where I add up points across categories, giving extra points for a working tailgate (Majorette!) or a beautifully modeled interior.  As I stated earlier - as soon as I picked up the vintage Majorette - I knew it was going to be the winner.  The Hot Wheels is a beautifully done piece - a steal at your local Wal-Mart/Target for just $5.50.  But the Majorette wins on size and scale alone - even before considering its authentic vintage nature.  If the Hot Wheels is a steal at $5.50, then the Majorette is an absolute steal on E-Bay - its common status meaning that its easy to find - and prices for even mint models (before factoring in shipping charges) aren't much more than that of the Hot Wheels at Wal-Mart. 

Check back to Matchbox Frenzy soon for hopefully another comparison post - and this time - perhaps the winner won't be pre-determined!








Friday, May 11, 2018

XK and F-Type Grand Tourers



























I really like the Jaguar F-Type fastback...  What a beautiful car...  And the best part of it is that Jaguar actually offers it in a manual transmission with a clutch!  Unfortunately the manual is offered only on the lower horsepower variants - but maybe that keeps me from spending the money on the 550 horsepower versions!

And now Matchbox has done a scale model of the F-Type...  It's a nice model, in black in the group photo to the right, but is a little let down by the clear plastic roof.  It would've looked great if they'd painted in the steel roof panels between the windshield and the moonroof, and between the moonroof and the rear hatchback.  But they didn't, leaving the model looking a little chintzy...   But also really good...  Its a nice model of a ridiculously nice car, just with a small error.  

And the cool thing is that this model replaced another super nice model of the XK hardtop (in maroon to the right).  This was frankly a wonderful model, made during Matchbox' late 2000's renaissance, of another exquisite real life Jaguar coupe.  I chose the maroon version for the photographs, both as a contrasting color and due to the ridiculously handsome wheels.  I have the model in 6 colors (see later photo of all 6), including 2 other red/maroon shades (3 red shades for one model!?!  4 of the six share the same handsome multi-spoke alloys, with only one having even nicer 5-spoke wheels (though I didn't include a photo such that you can see it) and the blue model having a slightly less attractive 5-spoke wheels that came with that premium series.  All in all, a great casting.

And the cool thing is that THAT casting also replaced an earlier very nice XK8 casting (the red convertible in the above photos).  I've got this casting in 3 colors, including the premium version I chose to highlight for the main photo shoot, (unfortunately I was only able to find 2 of the colors - I can't find my blue one).  

So in short, Matchbox has faithfully and excellently done the last 3 generations of Jaguar's beautiful grand touring line!  Time for a comparison of the 3 generations of Matchbox Jaguar XKs!

But once I started the comparison, I decided to include additional versions from other toy companies.  Hot wheels produced an interesting premium XK-8 coupe back around 1998 as part of its Adult Collectible Jaguar set (in blue)  This set cost $40 - a LOT of money back then.  It took a long time for me to decide to spend the money to buy the set!

But then later on they produced a Whips version (in green in the photos) with nicer wheels.  Overall its a nice casting, but there's always been something I didn't really like about it, something that was off about it... It just didn't have the same presence as the Matchbox versions... 

And then as I looked through my car cases I came across a Malibu entry - a silver XK hardtop....   And what a great model this one is!  Size-wise it is right in line (maybe a hair longer) than the equivalent excellent Matchbox XK hardtop.  But it's got actual plastic headlights and rear lights, great body detail, and authentic replicas of Jaguar's own alloy wheels!

Including these 2 additional models from Malibu and Hot Wheels made for a 5 model comparison test.  And while all the models are nice and worthy in their own right, it was easy to pick the winners and losers:

5th Place:  The Hot Wheels XK-8 hardtop.  These were the most expensive models and they felt like quality.  They also were the only model with an opening part (the hood).  However the most important thing about a model is the overall proportions, and the Hot Wheels casting doesn't quite get it right.  It's close, but not as close as the others, and to my eye, its not right.  Maybe its too rounded?  Or not long enough?  I can't tell what's wrong about it, but I can tell that it's not quite right.  Excellent paint, metal chassis, great detail, amazing wheels (green version) and rubber tires are all wonderful aspects, but they can't change the overall shape of the casting.  On a scale of 10, this casting is a nice 7, but it can't win when the other castings were all 7.5s and higher.

4th Place:  Matchbox F-Type (black hardtop in the group photo).  In real life this is the handsomest design, particularly from the back.  But cast in metal as a toy, the back and the rest of the design isn't quite as compelling (though the black paint that hides detail doesn't help...  perhaps in a different color it would score higher).  It's got nice wheels, that are shared with the previous generation XK.  But the real thing that relegated this model to second from last is the roof treatment, and the way that Matchbox cheaped out on painting the "metal" portions.  A 7.5 on a scale of 10.

3rd Place:  Matchbox XK-8 convertible (red in the group photo).  There is nothing wrong with this model to relegate it to a mid pack finish.  Its a nice model, (especially in premium trim with rubber tires).  Its realistic.  Its a pretty design (though not as pretty as the next generation).  Its a good (but lightweight) model that you should have in your collection.  It just lacks an absolute "gotta-have-it" quality or factor to propel it higher in the standings.  An 8 on a scale of 10.

2nd Place:  Matchbox 2nd generation XK coupe.  This is a great model.  Such a nice model that I was thinking about a blog post dedicated just to this model.  Big, handsome, wide, cool-looking, available in multiple colors and wheels.  A model that makes you want to buy the real car, that actually looks BETTER than the already great looking real car.  This model should have won the comparison test, if not for the dark horse Malibu model.  A solid 9 on a scale of 10.  Get it in every color you can find!

1st Place:  Malibu 2nd generation XK coupe.  Those Malibu designs were beautiful designs (aside from the under-scale VW transporter bus).  I have an entire blog post dedicated to the incredible efforts they made on Land Rovers a few years ago (Range Rover, Range Rover Sport, LR3, etc., all beautifully done!).  And this XK is done in the same quality vein.   Its everything that makes the Matchbox one a winner - turned up an extra notch.  The separate glass lights are a great touch, as are the factory correct wheels.  It lost a few points for weight and for the somewhat bland silver paint, but still managed to out-do the car that was a shoo-in to win this test.  A 9.5 on a 10 point scale...  With a metal bottom and in a color besides silver it could have been a 10!

Congrats to Malibu for a winning model, and to Matchbox for making 3 different well-modeled Jaguar Grand Touring cars!

P.S.  One problem that sometimes comes up with comparison tests is determining where to cut off the models included in the comparison tests...  After all, the mid-90's XKs replaced the aged XJ-S - should I have included scale model XJ-Ss? 

But in this case, the XJ-S, designed in the '70's, seemed like a more different car from the XK-8 than any of the models included in the test.  Plus, I don't have very good XJ-S models. 

Hot Wheels did a popular one in the '80s, but to my eyes it looks out of proportion - too long relative to its width, such that it would have easily taken last place in the above test.  And Corgi Jr. had an XJ-S model in the '80's (a bit less well known than the Hot Wheels model - at least here in the USA), that was the exact opposite of the Hot Wheels casting - much shorter and wider (chubbier?) though closer to true proportions.  The Corgi would have won hands down over the Hot Wheels, but probably still would have been beaten by all of the excellent XK-8 and later models.  Finally I have a very unusual Majorette premium model of an XJ-S cabriolet - however my casting is the only example of this model that I've ever seen!  Anyway, aside from the Majorette, the XJ-S castings seem somewhat bland and well known and I just wasn't excited to include them.  So I didn't!